Skip to main content

Thoughts: Melvin Upton Goes To The Six



On Tuesday, Padres GM AJ Preller struck a deal with the Toronto Blue Jays, sending resurgent outfielder Melvin Upton, Jr. to the 6 in exchange for 19-year old Dominican RHP Hansel Rodriguez, continuing the dismantling of the ill-fated 2015 “win-now” Padres squad. Additionally, the Padres will pay all but 5 million of the remaining balance of Upton’s contract.

While Preller hit a home run by flipping bullpen-arm-turned-All-Star pitcher Drew Pomernanz to the Red Sox for consensus top 25 prospect Anderson Espinoza, Preller struck out on this deal.

For one, Melvin Upton was one of the few Padres players who possessed any sort of tangible value that approached that of an everyday player. At the time of the trade, his Baseball Reference Wins Above Replacement, or bWAR, was valued at 1.9, which essentially correlates to a solid starter- tied for second on the team with Yangervis Solarte. 

In return, the Padres received Hansel Rodriguez, who is essentially a fringe prospect. His Fangraph Future Value (FV) projection is a 40 on a 20-80 scale, essentially placing his MLB future in the back of a big league rotation or the bullpen. This isn’t necessarily a bad result, but Rodriguez is only 19 years old- there’s a whole litany of issues that could arise- issues that have derailed the careers of much more talented players. Rodriguez will likely arrive in San Diego anywhere from four to six years down the line if his development goes smoothly, but this is FAR from a sure thing. 

In all honestly, these two things wouldn’t even make this a bad trade- IF the Blue Jays had agreed to take on Melvin’s gargantuan contract- but instead, the Padres are paying almost all of it on Toronto's behalf. To put this in context, Upton is owed the balance of over 30 million dollars for the last two seasons of the five-year contract he signed with the Braves. The only motivation for dealing Upton would have been the financial freedom afforded to the Padres by finding a team to absorb his contract- but alas, this is sadly not the case. The Padres are only saving five million dollars (how absurd this statement might sound to an average person is fully acknowledged), which will only allow Preller to plug a few holes in the roster with marginal talent.

It’s not like Upton was an incompetent player with the Padres. In fact, he was in the midst of a season that kinda-sorta-dare-I-say-it resembled a career revival.  He was even having a better season than his All-Star brother Justin, outpacing the latter in almost every major offensive statistic. Now, he was never going to be the potential 30-30 threat he once was at the start of the decade, but he had certainly been a serviceable starting outfielder, and a fan-favorite to boot. 

Almost unbelievably, Melvin Upton, Jr. will be the Upton brother everyone in this town will remember the fondest- especially because of that one really, really, really, really cool time he made the catch of the year. Let's watch that again.



Ahhh. That was fun. Good luck with everything in Toronto, Mel. Give Drake our warmest San Diego regards.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

.500

So.......... Raise your hand if you thought that 10 games in to the season, the Padres would be at .500? *waits patiently* Okay, now that we've gotten that out of the way: THE PADRES ARE AT .500! Not only that, but we've won two of our first three series- one of which was against the Giants, who have more or less dominated the NL West this decade. This is the same team that ESPN could not find a single reason to have hope for before the season kicked off. They couldn't be more wrong- this team is overflowing with reasons to hope.  First off, Manny Margot. The man looks like an absolute star in the making- before, we knew that he could be a first division regular easily. The only thing missing was the power- if it developed, he'd be a bona fide five-tool star. And boy, does it look like it's developing. He's currently tied for eighth in the league with three home runs, and has also shown impressive gap power.  Even though small sample size i...

This Team Makes Me Drink Turns 1- A Padres Game Celebration

Hard to believe that I've been writing this blog for an entire year now! It's even harder to believe that, of all things, I felt compelled to start This Team Makes Me Drink because I vehemently disagreed with Melvin Upton, Jr. being traded - that hot take ( Melvin Upton goes to the 6!!!) didn't age too well. I genuinely thought that I would write a couple posts, get bored, and completely forget about ever writing about sports again- but alas, here we are, a full trip around the sun later- and what better way to celebrate TTMMD turning a year old than by going to a Padre game ? And what a celebration it was. The Padres won, 7-5, splitting the series with the Mets, and more importantly, allowing me to experience my first Padres W in over two calendar years. My thoughts/stray observations from my experience are below, but first, a few acknowledgments: I'd like to give a big shoutout to my Mom being my #1 reader and for unfailingly promoting this blog on all of h...

Who Will Manage the Padres Next?

The 2019 season was the year the Padres were supposed to materialize their immense potential into tangible results on the field, and manager Andy Green was supposed to be the guy that led that charge.  Instead, 2019 was the year that the Padres abruptly pulled the plug on the Green administration after the team limped to the end of yet another lost season, only two years after they had extended his contract. 2019 was supposed to be different- and there were times when it was: the Padres were .500 at the All Star break for the first time in seemingly forever. However, they’ve been abysmal since then, sporting a 25-47 record since then.  Certainly, the onus for the Padres second half collapse does not fall squarely on Andy Green- but it appears that Barry Bloom of Forbes was (as much as I’m loathe to admit it) correct: Green had lost the respect of his players.  I mean- look at Wil Myers in this video; he can barely hide the smirk on his face when...